WASHINGTON: A firestorm erupted yesterday over Donald Trump’s call for a ban on Muslims entering the United States as religious leaders, the White House and his rivals on the presidential campaign roundly condemned the proposal. The leading candidate for the Republican presidential nomination made the provocative remarks – just his latest on a range of topics on the campaign trail – after last week’s shooting that left 14 dead in California by a Muslim couple said to have been radicalized.
In a rare primetime speech to the nation from the Oval Office on Sunday, President Barack Obama called the attack in San Bernardino an “act of terrorism” and vowed to defeat extremism, but also stressed that it was not “a war between America and Islam”. Less than 24 hours later, Trump’s bombastic bid for the White House plumbed what critics called a new low and triggered calls for him to be barred from taking power after he urged a “total and complete shutdown of Muslims entering the United States until our country’s representatives can figure out what is going on”.
In a speech late Monday, the 69-year-old billionaire real estate mogul and reality television star doubled down on his initial statement. “We have no choice,” Trump said, saying that Islamist radicals want to kill Americans. “It’s going to get worse and worse. We’re going to have more World Trade Centers,” he said, referring to the deadly attacks on Sept 11, 2001.
His comments were condemned by the White House as “totally contrary” to American values and similarly slammed as far afield as London and Cairo, where Egypt’s official religious body Dar al-Iftaa denounced them as “extremist and racist”. The strongest reaction came in the United States, including from Trump’s rivals in the race to run for the White House in 2016. Senator Lindsey Graham branded the remarks “un-American” and said Trump was only fueling radical Islam.
Trump was the “ISIL man of the year,” said Graham, referring to the extremist Islamic State group. “Do you know how you win this war? You side with people in the faith who reject this ideology, which is 99 percent,” Graham told CNN, before invoking Trump’s campaign slogan – “make America great again”. “And do you know how you make America great again?” asked Graham, who is lagging badly in the nomination race. “Tell Donald Trump to go to hell.” Other Republican contenders including Marco Rubio, John Kasich, Chris Christie and Jeb Bush, as well as Republican House Speaker Paul Ryan, also rejected Trump’s proposal.
Hillary Clinton, the Democratic presidential frontrunner, tweeted: “Declaring war on Islam or demonizing Muslim Americans is not only counter to our values – it plays right into the hands of terrorists.” And Rick Kriseman, the Democratic mayor of Saint Petersburg, Florida, tweeted: “I am hereby barring Donald Trump from entering St Petersburg until we fully understand the dangerous threat posed by all Trumps.”
Muslim leaders in the United States also hit out at Trump. Sohaib Sultan, Muslim Life Coordinator and Chaplain at Princeton University, was scathing, drawing parallels between Trump and the radical ideology of the Islamic State group. “ISIS is to Islam what Donald Trump is to American values: a complete distortion of everything that we as a country and a society stand for.” He added: “I think he’s clearly disqualified himself from being the president of the United States.” But Sultan also lambasted other Republicans. “I know a lot of Republican candidates are jumping on Trump about his latest comments, but a lot of Republican candidates have really been using similar type of rhetoric throughout the election cycle as well,” he told CNN.
Nihad Awad, executive director of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, added: “Donald Trump sounds more like a leader of a lynch mob than a great nation like ours.” But Trump was characteristically unrepentant yesterday, comparing the proposed ban to “presidential proclamations” made by Franklin D Roosevelt during World War II. Asked in an interview on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” program if his proposal went against treasured American values, he responded: “No, because FDR did it!”
But that failed to quell the firestorm, with Jeff Bezos, the Amazon founder who also set up the space company Blue Origin, tweeting: “Will still reserve him a seat on the Blue Origin rocket. #sendDonaldtospace.” The British government also weighed in. Prime Minister David Cameron “completely disagrees” with the remarks, which are “divisive, unhelpful and quite simply wrong,” a spokeswoman for the Conservative leader said. In Geneva, the United Nations refugee agency – though not directly responding to Trump’s remarks – warned that rhetoric in the US presidential campaign was threatening a key refugee resettlement program in the United States.
Trump campaign manager Corey Lewandowski, asked in an email if the shutdown would apply specifically to immigration or more broadly to student visas, tourists and other travelers to the United States, replied: “Everyone.” In Mount Pleasant, South Carolina, Trump dismissed his critics. He told a rally that mosques in the United States should also be scrutinized. “We have to see what’s happening,” he said.
Keywords trending on social media after Trump’s statement included Hitler, shutdown and immigration. But conservative pundit Ann Coulter wrote “GO TRUMP, GO!” on the social media site. A spokesman for Republican presidential candidate Ben Carson, Doug Watts, said Carson did not believe that religion should be a litmus test for entry to the country but said everyone visiting the United States should be monitored during their stay, saying that is the case in many countries.
White House spokesman Josh Earnest told MSNBC that Trump is “seeking to tap into a darker side, a darker element, and try to play on people’s fears in order to build support for his campaign”. Whether Trump will pay a price for the move is unclear. He has shown a proclivity toward insulting people with no penalty, from saying a storied Vietnam veteran, Senator John McCain, is not a hero to blasting Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly.
Trump said in an interview on Fox News that his proposal would not prevent Muslims who are serving overseas in the US military from returning and would not apply to people already living in the country, “except that we have to be vigilant”, he said. To support his proposal, Trump pointed to data from the conservative think-tank Center for Security Policy indicating that a quarter of Muslims in a poll thought violence against Americans was justified. The center’s president, Frank Gaffney Jr, has been critical of Muslims in America, and the Southern Poverty Law Center, a civil rights group, calls him “one of America’s most notorious Islamaphobes”. – Agencies